2 ways to fix the Chicago White Sox before the trade deadline
The Chicago White Sox are a broken team. The White Sox started a rebuild in late 2016, telling fans this was the beginning of a process that would ultimately lead to the team winning multiple World Series Championships in the 2020s. So far, that hasn’t really worked out.
Following last year’s ALDS destruction by the Houston Astros, the Chicago White Sox needed to get better in the off-season but instead got worse.
Carlos Rodon departed the team without getting so much as a qualifying offer and the second base hole was left void save for replacement-level players. All in all, offseason acquisitions Josh Harrison, Leury Garcia, AJ Pollock, Kendall Graveman, and Joe Kelly have amounted to roughly zero WAR, although Johnny Cueto has at least been good.
If the White Sox had actually tried this offseason and signed players like Marcus Semien, Carlos Rodon, and Kyle Schwarber, they would probably be in first place or close to it but that is something they refused to do. Alas, they have a lot of ground to makeup and not a lot of talent to do it with.
The Chicago White Sox needs to make win-now moves to turn this season around.
Some suggest the White Sox should now be sellers at the deadline. This is the wrong move. First of all, it would be quitting in a way similar to the team’s infamous 1997 white flag trade.
Secondly, the AL Central is an incredibly weak division and the AL Wild Card race isn’t very stacked either. Theoretically, even a solid White Sox team could sneak into the playoffs. Unfortunately, they aren’t that right now and won’t be with the current roster.
Thirdly, if anyone deserves to go through another rebuild with this team, it shouldn’t be Rick Hahn who needs to save this current roster in order to keep his job and what’s left of his reputation.
The last time Rick Hahn was pressed with the task of saving face on his roster, he traded Fernando Tatis Jr. for “Big Game” James Shields. That is a move that will forever live in infamy, even if Tatis proves to be injury-prone for most of his career.
I don’t really trust Rick Hahn to identify the players that will help turn this team around but since that’s really the only option left, it’s time to zero in on trades that will turn this team around.
The Chicago White Sox needs to make some upgrades across certain positions.
Trade for Mike Trout:
It might be a pipe dream but it’s the one thing that would for sure turn this team around. The Angels have proven that they can’t win with Mike Trout so it might be worth it to trade him and build around Shohei Ohtani who is younger.
If a Mike Trout trade is a possibility, the White Sox should come calling because there’s no team that could benefit more from a Trout acquisition than the Chicago White Sox.
If Trout can turn the Sox season around and get them winning in the playoffs, it would cement his legacy as one of the greatest players to ever play the game.
Why would the Angels do this? Because the team is going absolutely nowhere as they have for several seasons now. With Mike Trout nearing age 31, he’s about to enter into the decline phase of his career and his big contract might prevent the Angels from re-signing Ohtani.
Plus, the Chicago White Sox have players both in their major and minor league systems that could be of great interest to the Angels. And no, you wouldn’t have to trade an entire team for him because taking on Trout’s contract and declining years would lessen his trade value.
After bypassing Bryce Harper and Manny Machado, the White Sox have the flexibility to add Trout’s salary to their payroll and this is the one thing that would salvage the reputation of the front office and ownership with the fans.
Trade for Ian Happ:
The Cubs infielder/outfielder is the kind of player that Tony La Russa thinks Leury Garcia is. Happ would be especially helpful at positions the Sox have struggled at this season, particularly left field, right field, and second base.
Acquiring him would take at-bats away from Leury Garcia and Josh Harrison, something that is desperately needed. Most importantly, Happ would provide a good bat for a team that desperately needs one.
Of course, it’s a question if the Cubs would be willing to trade Happ to the White Sox, especially without getting a lot in return. The White Sox can’t afford to overpay for him as they did for Craig Kimbrel so Rick Hahn should not even think about including someone like Colson Montgomery in this trade.
They should instead try to trick the Cubs by offering a prospect of theirs they secretly know is overrated. Regardless, he would be the perfect addition to this team so they should consider trading for him.
Trade for Jose Quintana:
The former White Sox pitcher is having a solid season with the Pittsburgh Pirates and it shouldn’t take too much to re-acquire him. I don’t know how he fits into the rotation but we’re not at a point where the White Sox don’t have a need for more pitching arms, especially left-handed ones.
The Chicago White Sox needs to make some big-time changes with their caches.
Coaching Changes:
“Fire Tony” has become a popular chant at Chicago White Sox home games thanks to their manager’s ineptitude in making decisions.
He is simply not equipped to manage the modern game. He also may have played a role in sucking the life out of the team, as they just look bored at this point. They’re also boring to watch.
Unfortunately, we know Tony La Russa isn’t going anywhere as long as Jerry Reinsdorf owns this team at least for this season. So for now, the coaching changes need to revolve around lower-level coaches, some of whom should be replaced to give these players better guidance and instruction.
Fire Frank Menechino:
You can blame the players if you want. You can also blame injuries. But the pathetic batting results of Yoan Moncada, Eloy Jimenez, and Yasmani Grandal lie primarily at the fault of the coaching staff. There’s no reason that these guys should be this bad at hitting.
We’ve also seen guys like Gavin Sheets do better with the AAA coach than with Menechino. I don’t care if the players like him, he’s done an awful job so replacing Menechino would be the right move. Since the AAA hitting coach has done more for the Sox this year than Menechino has, a promotion may be in order.
Fire Joe McEwing:
I’m not sure what Joe McEwing has been doing as the third base coach of the White Sox but this team has some of the worst base runnings I’ve ever seen. They’ve lost a chance to win several games because they ran themselves out on the bases.
While firing McEwing might not necessarily make this team better, it certainly would not make this team any worse. For a replacement, I would suggest AJ Pierzynski, which could give him the coaching experience he needs to manage the team next season.