2B Whit Merrifield
Merrifield is a well-rounded player who could stick around in the long run. The three-time All-Star and former World Series champion has proven to be a contact hitter who routinely puts the ball in play, resulting in a career strikeout rate of 15.9%.
Merrifield is also a smart baserunner and was the AL Stolen Base leader in 2017, 2018, and 2021. Though he primarily plays second, Merrifield can also play in the outfield if necessary. Two bonuses are that he’s healthy and played for the Royals, which is Chris Getz’s weak spot.
The Phillies still owe Merrifield $1 million as part of his buyout, which would help the Sox get him at a discount. Chicago shouldn’t be spooked by Merrifield’s setback year and should buy low while they can.
Signing him to a two or three-year deal worth $18-25 million would be a worthwhile investment in a thin second baseman market.
3B Gio Urshela
Urshela is the best value third baseman available this offseason.
His career averages of .273 batting, .316 on-base, and .413 slugging have made him a dependable starter with the Yankees, Angels, Tigers, and Braves. Urshela also has a stellar reputation at the hot corner. In 2020 and 2022 he ranked top five in putouts and assists among AL third basemen.
The Sox shouldn’t hesitate to lock him up to a short-term deal. Neither Bryan Ramos nor Miguel Vargas are anywhere close to Urshela’s maturity and, despite turning 33 on October 11, Urshela’s efficiency and cost far outweigh his injury risk.
A three-year contract in the $20-25 million range would be the best contract Urshela has ever had, and it’s a great sign for an everyday starter.