The White Sox have not yet made a move to address their biggest offseason need: the starting rotation. Unless you consider Alec Marsh, who hasn’t pitched in the big leagues in two years, a meaningful upgrade, all of the work is still to be done. It’s not the fault of the White Sox, as the starting pitching free agent market has yet to start moving, and it’s expected to in the next two weeks prior to the lockout. For now, all we have are rumors, and Chicago has been connected to many starting pitchers in the rumor mill. Some would be impact pitchers at the top of the rotation, and others would be little more than depth. Here’s how the White Sox should prioritize the options.
1. RHP Freddy Peralta, TB
Not a ton is known about Freddy Peralta’s free-agent market, and it may not fully develop until Tarik Skubal makes his decision. ESPN’s Alden Gonzalez connected the Padres to Peralta, and they’ve been connected to nearly every other starter on the market. USA Today’s Bob Nightengale mentioned Peralta and Michael King as realistic options for the White Sox, so I’m guessing there's definitely interest here. Peralta suffered the worst stretch of his career in the first half of 2026, but looked much more like himself after a deadline deal sent him to Tampa Bay. Aside from his tough first half, Peralta has been a front-end starter for the past six years, consistently posting a sub-4 ERA and an elevated strikeout rate. He won’t turn 31 until June, so he should have several good years left in the tank. Peralta may cost $25-30 million a season, and I think it would be a worthwhile investment. He should be Chicago’s top target this winter.
Freddy Peralta pounds his chest after completing 6 scoreless innings 😤 pic.twitter.com/NwJsrLfpjX
— MLB (@MLB) October 14, 2026
2. RHP Michael King, SD
A talented right-hander who spent the first five years of his career in the Yankees bullpen, King made the transition to the rotation with San Diego seamlessly. In three seasons as a starter, he’s never posted an ERA above 3.50, and he reached his career-high with 185 innings in 2026. King will turn 32 in May, but he has an unusually low amount of innings on his arm for someone his age due to his late transition to starting. His stuff grades out strong, but an increase in his SIERA over the past three seasons are enough to be concerned that he may not thrive in a less favorable environment for pitchers. I still think King can anchor a starting rotation, but a shorter track record and a couple of concerning underlying metrics are enough to push him behind Peralta in my priority rankings for the White Sox. He’s been connected to Chicago by both Bob Nightengale on Foul Territory and Jesse Rogers on Chuck Garfein’s podcast.
Eight strikeouts for Michael King 🔥
— MLB (@MLB) September 30, 2026
He's through seven shutout innings! pic.twitter.com/KqUO5miIq7
3. RHP Kaima Taira, NPB
For the second straight offseason, the White Sox seem to be in pursuit of talent from Japan. The Score’s Bruce Levine connected both Chicago teams to righty Kaima Taira, a 27-year-old flamethrower from the Seibu Lions. Taira has pitched in both starting and relief roles in Japan, and his numbers as a starter were impressive in 2026. The main drawback to Taira is his frame. He’s just 5-foot-8 and 220 pounds, and there’s very little track record of a starter with a similar frame succeeding in the big leagues. While I love the upside here, I think it’s a bit risky to make Taira the big pitching acquisition for the White Sox. As much as they may believe in his upside as a starter, there’s a possibility his skillset doesn’t translate to MLB, or that he can’t stick as a starter. I don’t mind taking a shot at the upside here, but he shouldn’t be the only arm they add, or even the biggest.
This is Kaima Taira. He is 5-foot-8, 220 pounds and throws up to 100 mph. He also might be the best starting pitcher available this winter outside of Tarik Skubal. More on him, Teruaki Sato (the class’ best hitter) and Hiromi Itoh: https://t.co/cOHKPO8tDn pic.twitter.com/yHTSuY7Zc7
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) September 10, 2026
4. RHP Nick Pivetta, SD
In the same interview where he connected the White Sox to Michael King, ESPN’s Jesse Rogers mentioned some interest in his San Diego teammate Nick Pivetta as well. After four seasons in the Red Sox rotation, Pivetta joined the Padres ahead of 2025 and had the best season of his career, with a 2.87 ERA in 31 starts. His results in 2026 were good, though he was limited to just eight starts due to multiple instances of elbow soreness. Pivetta will turn 34 in February, so he’s unlikely to command a significant long-term contract, but could be a good upside play on a one or two year deal. The elbow soreness is scary for me even though he returned healthy for the playoffs, and I’m not sure I trust a 34-year-old to bounce back to his 2025 form at this stage. I don’t mind taking a chance on Pivetta as a second addition, but making him the biggest upgrade to the rotation is risky.
7 innings, 1 hit allowed from Nick Pivetta 😤 pic.twitter.com/UzivGLJdWC
— MLB (@MLB) March 31, 2025
5. RHP Hiromi Itoh, NPB
The White Sox don’t seem to be stopping their Japanese scouting with Kaima Taira, as a report from Francys Romero indicates that Hiromi Itoh could be on their radar as well. Itoh, 29, won the Japanese equivalent of the Cy Young award in 2025 but took a bit of a step back this season. He doesn’t have overwhelming stuff and relies on throwing many pitches and changing speeds to find success. While he may have a higher floor than someone like Taira, Itoh’s ceiling is somewhat limited by his lack of excellent stuff. He profiles as a back-end rotation arm, and there’s always extra risk added when joining a new league with stronger competition. If the White Sox want to take a chance on him as an innings-eater, I’m not opposed. But signing Itoh shouldn’t prevent or inhibit them from pursuing a stronger option to anchor the rotation.
Hiromi Itoh took a no-hitter into the 7th and racks up 10 strikeouts! 🗣️
— Yakyu Cosmopolitan (@yakyucosmo) August 11, 2026
7.1 IP, 3 H, 1 ER, 4 BB, 10 K, 124 P, 14 Whiffs
However, he exits after allowing the go-ahead run in the 8th 🥀 pic.twitter.com/bQXNhYGOlK
6. RHP Dustin May
Chicago is one of a handful of teams being connected to recent World Series champion Dustin May, who took some steps forward this season despite his traditional numbers not showing it. A former top prospect of the Dodgers, May has finally gotten a chance to establish himself as a starter the past two seasons and the results have been mixed. The number of teams connected to May is significant, meaning the right-hander could end up receiving a larger contract than originally anticipated. I’d prefer the White Sox stay away from that and save their likely limited financial resources to sign a more proven frontline arm. I suppose that May would be a fine depth addition, but he should by no means be Plan A.
Dustin May finishes the first complete game AND shutout of his career 😤 pic.twitter.com/tXWltetICr
— MLB (@MLB) June 16, 2026
Other arms the White Sox could pursue but have not yet been directly linked to include: Trevor Rogers, Clay Holmes, Kevin Gausman, and Casey Mize.
