Skip to main content

White Sox ideal move after Luis Castillo trade could change their entire offseason grade

Luis Castillo's money off the books completely changes the White Sox offseason
ByNoah Phalen
Sep 22, 2026; Kansas City, Missouri, USA;  Chicago White Sox pitcher Luis Castillo (58) pitches during the ninth inning against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: William Purnell-Imagn Images
Sep 22, 2026; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Chicago White Sox pitcher Luis Castillo (58) pitches during the ninth inning against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: William Purnell-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

In a stunning move Thursday evening, the White Sox traded their longest tenured player, Davis Martin, to the Rockies alongside Luis Castillo. In return, the White Sox landed left-hander Sean Sullivan and 17-year-old catcher Dougal Veliz. The most important part of the deal for Chicago isn’t the return, however, but the fact that the Colorado Rockies are taking on the entirety of Castillo’s contract. Castillo was set to make $25.1 million this season, with a $25 million option for 2028 that vests with 180 innings pitched in 2027. Having that money off their books could completely change the outlook for the rest of the offseason for the White Sox. 

Luis Castillo’s stint with the White Sox didn’t work out well for either side. The White Sox traded promising catcher Boston Smith for him at the deadline and Castillo posted an 8.42 ERA in 31 innings with Chicago. With another expensive year on his contract, it seemed the White Sox would need to just hope that he could turn things around in 2027.

The White Sox now have $20+ million more to spend on pitching this winter

The White Sox have made clear on multiple occasions that improving the starting rotation is their biggest priority this offseason, and they’ve already added righty Dustin May on a three-year deal. James Fegan of the Chicago Sun Times indicated on Wednesday before the Castillo trade that the White Sox were still looking for another starting pitcher of “similar magnitude”. It wasn’t exactly the news White Sox fans wanted to hear. The White Sox biggest need is starting pitching that they can comfortably pencil into the rotation for a playoff series, and May is a bit of a question mark at this point. Adding an arm a tier above May still feels like the most important thing. Perhaps someone like Clay Holmes was the best fans would be able to hope for before. But with those extra dollars, the calculus could be changed.

I don’t expect the White Sox to pursue Tarik Skubal, even though technically they have the means. But several other top arms are still available on the market. Rays free-agent Freddy Peralta is still my favorite starting pitcher in the class, and he’s likely to demand a contract that would be the White Sox franchise record. I’m not sure he was in play before, but maybe he is now. Jim Bowden of The Athletic did mention the White Sox as one of the teams in the mix for Peralta in a report late Thursday night. In theory, the White Sox could offer Peralta $30 million a season, and it would only raise the payroll about five million from where it was projected to be with Castillo. 

Outside of Peralta, righty Michael King and lefty Trevor Rogers are top-of-the-rotation type arms who could make a big impact and will likely command a hefty contract. Both are players the White Sox could consider with their newfound cash. The other option is to remain shopping in the lower tier of starting pitching and spend bigger on an outfield bat– maybe someone like Seiya Suzuki– or a bigger name closer to replace Grant Taylor. 

Whichever direction the White Sox choose to go, they now have an extra $25 million to play with and it opens the door for greater possibilities than were potentially available before. Chris Getz still has a couple weeks to put the money to good use, so we’ll see what he’s got in mind.

Add us as a preferred source on Google