Skip to main content

Why Dustin May deal should completely change White Sox free-agent pitching priority

The White Sox need to chase stability, not upside, with remaining pitching acquisitions
ByNoah Phalen
Oct 24, 2026; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA;  Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch against the Tampa Bay Rays during the fifth inning in game two of the 2026 World Series at American Family Field.  Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images
Oct 24, 2026; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch against the Tampa Bay Rays during the fifth inning in game two of the 2026 World Series at American Family Field. Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Chicago White Sox have made their first significant move of what is expected to be an accelerated offseason, landing righty Dustin May on a three-year deal. The signing represents an upside swing for Chicago in an offseason that is certain to feature several additions to the pitching staff. Prior to the May signing, the White Sox were connected in rumors to many different starting pitchers, including Japanese righty Kaima Taira. While I don’t believe the team is done looking for upgrades to their rotation, landing May should change the priority moving forward, and adding Taira no longer makes a ton of sense. 

Let’s start with May, a former top prospect who has dealt with a slew of injuries throughout his career. The past two seasons were really his first opportunities to be a full-time starting pitcher at the bottom league level, and the results were mixed. He struggled in 2025 with the Dodgers and Red Sox, but had a much better start with the Cardinals in 2026 before a deadline trade to Milwaukee. May’s results faltered down the stretch, but the underlying metrics remained pretty strong. His FIP was comparable to Sean Burke in 2026, so it seems like only a matter of time before the results start showing. Still, it’s risky, since he’s never actually posted those results at the big league level. Is there upside to be unlocked here? Sure. And I don’t mind the White Sox taking a swing, but they can’t afford to shoot for upside and accept high risk with all of their additions.

The White Sox remaining pitching additions need to be proven and dependable

Take, for example, Kaima Taira. Multiple insiders have reported on the White Sox interest in him, and the fit certainly made some sense as one of the higher-risk, higher-reward arms in the free agent class. Taira has excellent stuff, but concerns about his size and inexperience starting games give him a fairly substantial reliever risk. Adding him to a rotation that already features first-time starter Grant Taylor and unproven Dustin May would create a rotation with three question marks behind Sean Burke. There’s a world where Taira, May, and Taylor all turn into excellent starting options, but there are many other scenarios where things go wrong. None of the three have proven they can go deep into games and consistently get batters out in a starting role at the big league level, and that’s what the White Sox should be looking for moving forward. 

The White Sox have taken their swing at upside, and they now need to fill out their rotation with dependable veteran arms they’d be comfortable giving the ball to in a playoff game. I’d still love them to target Freddy Peralta or Michael King, who can provide frontline upside along with dependability, but if they don’t want to swing that big, veterans like Sonny Gray, Kevin Gausman, or Clay Holmes could make a ton of sense. 

As enticing as Taira’s upside is, I think the White Sox need to pivot elsewhere for their remaining pitching needs. Dustin May could be a solid backend starter addition for Chicago, but if he’s the main add that they’re going to rely on, we could be in for a disappointing 2027.

Add us as a preferred source on Google