The free-agent market is saturated with options for MLB teams looking for starting pitching this winter. The White Sox are definitely one of those teams, and they’ve already added one arm after reportedly agreeing to a three-year deal with righty Dustin May. It seems like the White Sox aren’t done adding arms, but the significant financial commitment given to May could force them to take a creative approach in continuing to add. One such possibility is the trade market. There figures to be quite a few arms available for trade this winter, but that number has decreased after the Mariners and Royals completed a blockbuster on Wednesday.
BREAKING: The Seattle Mariners are acquiring Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garcia in a trade with the Kansas City Royals, sources tell ESPN. The Royals are receiving three major league pitchers in return, headlined by right-hander Bryce Miller. It's a six-man deal.
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) November 18, 2026
When thinking about teams with a pitching surplus, Seattle was the first team that came to mind for a lot of people. The Mariners projected rotation for 2027 included Logan Gilbert, Bryan Woo, Bryce Miller, George Kirby, and Emerson Hancock, with top prospects Kade Anderson and Ryan Sloan also waiting in the wings. It seemed like that Seattle would move at least one of their starters, and they did. Some had speculated that the White Sox could be a good match for Seattle in a trade, but that seems highly unlikely now. In fact, Mariners GM Jerry DiPoto went as far as to say there is “Zero chance” the Mariners trade another starter. If the White Sox thought there was a match there, they’ll now have to pivot.
White Sox still have payroll flexibility and creativity to land frontline arm
Even with Dustin May on payroll, the White Sox financial commitments should leave wiggle room to spend. Freddy Peralta or Michael King would be the type of high-profile pitching addition fans are hoping for, but both will likely have a highly competitive market that will only become more prevalent once Tarik Skubal signs. Either would likely take the largest contract in White Sox history. Sonny Gray has signed with the Twins, taking a potential fallback option off the board. If the White Sox aren’t willing to pay up for a premiere arm financially, it could be a trade that gets them the arm they need.
Trades are much more difficult to predict than free agent signings, so it’s not clear which controllable arms are available via trade. Angels lefty Reid Detmers was a popular name at the trade deadline, but Los Angeles elected to hold onto him and likely will until they have a new GM in place. Other starting pitchers available for trade may come with short-term contracts, which wouldn’t be the ideal scenario for a young White Sox team looking to build an extended run of competitive years.
I’m interested in seeing what Chris Getz and the front office have planned for the two weeks leading up to the lockout, which would certainly explain any hesitancy to commit to a player on a short term contract. It would be incredibly surprising if Chicago walked away without another starter, but options are starting to drop off the board. Not just players like Sonny Gray, but entire team trade possibilities.
Buckle up, Sox fans. It’s going to be a chaotic 14 days leading up to December 2nd.
